Oak BluffsPequot Hotel in Oak Bluffs. They have 32 rooms in the main house, the middle house, and the annex building, which is where we stayed. They are located on a quiet street in a residential neighborhood just blocks away from the beach, downtown area with shopping and restaurants, and the ferry dock. The breakfast included quiche, hard-boiled eggs, fresh fruit, and a variety of pastries. They have cookies available in the afternoon and evenings and coffee and tea all day long. On the Friday night that we were there they had a "Porch Party" with wine, snacks, and live music.
I don't think it's an understatement to say that we fell in love with this place. The staff was friendly and there was a welcoming atmosphere.